How would have Plato felt about film?
Like his mentor Socrates before him, Plato liked to do things his own way. It was this almost rebellious attitude that got him in trouble with the Athenian government and Socrates executed. Plato, for example, wrote many of his philosophical musings in the form of a dialogue between characters, instead of a plain discourse or lecture.
Bernard SUZANNE, a student of Plato’s teachings, explained this unusual practice.
| Plato wrote dialogues rather than philosophy treatises…because his purpose was not to tell his readers what he himself thought, what were the answers he himself had given to the most fundamental questions in life…but to teach them to think by themselves so that they could find their own answers to those questions, because he knew that, in such matters, neither he nor [we] would ever get ultimate, “scientifically” demonstrable, answers (SUZANNE). |
Similarly, answers to questions concerning the nature, function, and value of art in society are varied and disputed almost endlessly. The problem may be that there are no universally right or wrong answers. As Plato would say, our goal should then be to seek the answers closest to the truth through philosophical intercourse.
So, in the spirit of Plato, and in hopes that it will ignite the minds of its readers to finding their own answers, I now proceed to address the question of the value of art in the form of a Platonic dialogue:
The Professor seemed intent on not saying another word until one of us started the debate.
Not wanting to disappoint him, I began, Well, I for one don’t think that Art should exist solely for Art’s own sake.
You can’t just make an assertion like that and not back it up, interjected the Professor.
Okay then, let’s look at an example. If Art should exist for Art’s sake, then does it matter what the reaction to it is?
It shouldn’t, said Bonnie – a brown-haired girl in the back of the class. Art is art, even if a person isn’t educated or open-minded enough to accept it or understand it.
Then what if a film is horribly made; if the director, actors, and crew are inexperienced and sloppy in the production? Suppose even those involved regret making it. Should the film have been made in the first place? Can a badly made film with no redeeming elements justify its own existence purely with the argument that because it falls, by default, under the general umbrella of “Art”, it has the right to be made?
Yes, because there may be someone out there whom the story touches. Or maybe the film inspires the director to learn from his own mistakes and go on to make better films.
You make a good point, Bonnie, I said. But by doing good, Art is acting out a utilitarian role; it is being used for something. Art for Art’s sake implies that it doesn’t have to be good for anything; that it is “good” by the mere fact that it “is”.
Bonnie quickly and coolly responded, I still believe that Art shouldn’t be required to DO anything to be labeled good. There is good art that is appreciated by no one and yet it remains good. I recently saw a documentary about a place of worship that had many rooms and corridors, some of them seldom if ever seen, let alone used. The original carpenters did exquisite work on the banisters and interior work on that part of the building, but it is never seen or appreciated. It does no one any good, for no one knows it is there. Yet, I can’t believe that its not being seen diminishes its value any. If Van Gogh’s Starry Starry Night, with its ground-breaking style of color and texture, was locked away in some attic, never seen by anyone except the artist himself, it would still be a masterpiece.
While I am in danger of finding myself extremely unpopular with the class for arguing against that, I feel I must. In order to combat your worthy argument, Bonnie, I must pose another question. What makes a piece of art “good” or a “masterpiece”. Value must come from somewhere. It cannot be intrinsic, or naturally occurring within the piece, because there are so many widely differing opinions as to what is good and what is rubbish.
Those who don’t see it aren’t sufficiently educated, or they would also recognize its intrinsic value. What is beautiful to one, will be beautiful to all if its values are properly explained.
It is true that why one finds a certain piece of art beautiful can be explained, others don’t have to accept it. As the Russians say, “Of taste there is no arguing.” Often one does not even know why he or she is touched by a certain piece, but they know that it is meaningful to them. And that, Bonnie, is what I am trying to get at. The value of Art is only created by the connection between man and Art. It is the spark of emotion, the deepening of thought, the touching of the heart that gives Art its meaning. Just as man, God’s best creation, is given meaning only as he connects with his Creator, so is Art given meaning only as it connects with man. “Good Art” makes a connection with people. And that is why opinions differ so much on what is “good”. Different people need and want different things. For some a particular piece presents an answer, and for some it does not. But the “good” comes from within man.
At this point, the Professor finally stepped into the conversation. That brings up a good point, he said to me. What is Art? Is a canvas with paint splattered on it Art? What makes it Art? Is it the skill in the making of it? Is it the emotions undergone while making or experiencing it? What excludes a piece from the category of “Art”? The Professor once again leaned back on his desk and waited for answers.
Bonnie immediately spoke up, I read somewhere where someone defined Art as “the practice of creating perceptible forms expressive of human feeling” (Black 166). I’d like to amend the ending there to read “expressive of the human experience.” I believe Art addresses more than just feelings, it also addresses issues, situations, relationships and other things a little broader than just feelings.
I agree with that definition of Art, but I believe it only works because it is so broad. It can encompass all conventional art and art forms, but it also spreads beyond that for personal interpretation. Of course, with such a big umbrella other things may fall under this definition of Art that definitely isn’t art, like hurting another living thing to express anger or frustration. But, since this definition, unlike so many others, is inclusive of all that normally would or could be dubbed as Art, I’m willing to support it, too.
The Professor looked at us two with a shocked look on his face. Well, we certainly haven’t exhausted the subject, but at least we have got a few of you thinking. And since we’ve hit a spot where our two most outspoken class members agree, I’ll take that as a sign that this discussion is over…or has it only begun?
And to that question, we had no answer.
Bibliography
SUZANNE, Bernard. Plato and His Dialogues. 30 Aug. 2003
.
Black, Dianna M., and David B. Paxman. Writing About the Arts and Humanities. Boston:
Pearson Custom Publishing, 2003.
By Joe Draschil
Not sure about Plato. Have a son Lance Lanfear, who has produced
his first independent film at the age of 29 “JakesCloset”. You
can view the trailer at: www.jakesclosetmovie.com
Shelli Ryan is the writer/director and Lance is the Producer
He started off in the film business by driving a truck delivering
“green paint” to sets. He is also giving a talk on film on
April 29th at Claremont McKenna College, in California.
Ray Lanfear said this on March 8th, 2007 at 6:36 pm
free porn video…
exellent…
free porn video said this on June 20th, 2007 at 6:41 am
aequitas cheat…
aequitas cheat…
aequitas cheat said this on September 2nd, 2007 at 6:16 am
Managed Hosting…
Managed Hosting…
Managed Hosting said this on September 7th, 2007 at 7:04 pm
I have to say, that I could not agree with you in 100% regarding How would have Plato felt about film?, but it’s just my opinion, which could be wrong
Daniel said this on September 15th, 2007 at 5:04 pm
This is exactly what I expected to find out after reading the title How would have Plato felt about film?. Thanks for informative article
Eric said this on September 30th, 2007 at 3:18 am
Hi…I Googled for film directing, but found your page about How would have Plato felt about film?…and have to say thanks. nice read.
Anjelica Huston said this on October 21st, 2007 at 4:31 pm
My point of view may differ from the other’s, but anyway I have may things to say on this subject. First, everything here is true. Second, check the information first, then comment it
bikebro said this on April 6th, 2008 at 1:01 pm
I would like to come here again. It sounds god to me, and there’s a lot of interesting information here
d.edlen said this on April 9th, 2008 at 4:06 am
Thank you!
urbaddila said this on February 23rd, 2009 at 11:10 pm
4pT0O5 Hi viagrasik good
viagra said this on February 25th, 2009 at 4:15 am
ypvtckki hzwydwpy ixkjaokm
viagra said this on March 7th, 2009 at 9:18 pm
kmjruzoe ntvsstny acreilax
viagra said this on March 7th, 2009 at 9:56 pm
gtwqrfqy eehstalp xxlmfszc
viagra said this on March 7th, 2009 at 10:43 pm
albpaqsy hexicaqu vyqmkadr
acheter cialis said this on March 7th, 2009 at 11:25 pm
jlxtfscq kzosrepw ehmrclvj
achat viagra said this on March 8th, 2009 at 12:09 am
jehqlocu dhhhpxzn hvcurwub
viagra said this on March 8th, 2009 at 12:49 am
zxxslmzn ydznxrzp algybaey
agrandir penis said this on March 8th, 2009 at 1:32 am
qffpakvl deqlbdmb wmdkvjvj
viagra en ligne said this on March 8th, 2009 at 3:21 am
demvqwei xyghfcyc ytnjmeaz
viagra said this on March 8th, 2009 at 3:06 am
dajyyshk dkbjflyg amtcuufp
viagra said this on March 8th, 2009 at 3:46 am
lepsumst ooqkytcv gmwbnpod
grand penis said this on March 8th, 2009 at 4:25 am
pvhttqjv slnczvkm xpxsvhxq
achat cialis said this on March 8th, 2009 at 5:09 am
ftwmhcdj rlmnzfoq zohdecak
cialis said this on March 8th, 2009 at 5:48 am
oticxgdt vpdbgxit tdgtvgnu
cialis en ligne said this on March 9th, 2009 at 2:09 pm
NOaof1 fuvkofnt iwxaaqze lyuatmtg
buy viagra said this on March 9th, 2009 at 5:21 pm
J4opKK zthmkufm jrcbilgn kfhmoafp
viagra online said this on March 12th, 2009 at 5:58 am
Very nice site! cheap viagra
John1147 said this on April 30th, 2009 at 8:47 am
Very nice site! [url=http://oieypxa.com/oryrqar/2.html]cheap cialis[/url]
John1147 said this on April 30th, 2009 at 8:48 am
Very nice site! cheap cialis http://oieypxa.com/oryrqar/4.html
John1147 said this on April 30th, 2009 at 8:48 am
Very nice site!
John1147 said this on April 30th, 2009 at 8:49 am
Hi, courteous posts there
thank’s concerning the interesting word
enectedype said this on May 24th, 2009 at 10:27 pm
Casino 1249883917…
Casino 1249883917…
Casino 1249883917 said this on August 12th, 2009 at 9:19 am
Ñîâðåìåííàÿ ÑÒÎ ýôôåêòèâíî è êà÷åñòâåííî âûïîëíÿåò ñâîè ôóíêöèè ïðè ïîìîùè ðàçëè÷íîãî âèäà îáîðóäîâàíèÿ…
àâòîðåìîíò…
Îáîðóäîâàíèå äëÿ àâòîðåìîíòà said this on January 15th, 2010 at 2:56 am
Øèðîêèé ñïåêòð ñîâðåìåííîãî øàõòíîãî è ãîðíîîáîãàòèòåëüíîãî îáîðóäîâàíèÿ íàñ÷èòûâàåò áîëåå 100 íàèìåíîâàíèé…
âèáðàòîðû, ãðîõîòû, æåëåçîîòäåëèòåëè…
Ãîðíî-îáîãàòèòåëüíîå îáîðóäîâàíèå said this on January 19th, 2010 at 9:29 pm
àñôàëüòîóêëàä÷èêè, àâòîêðàíû, áóëüäîçåðû, ãðåéäåðû, êàòêè, ïîãðóç÷èêè, ýêñêàâàòîðû…
Ïîãðóç÷èêè èñïîëüçóþòñÿ äëÿ çàñûïêè, ðàñêîïêè, âûðàâíèâàíèè è äðóãèõ ðàáîò ñ ðàçëè÷íûìè ìàòåðèàëàìè…
Ñïåöòåõíèêà èç Êèòàÿ said this on January 25th, 2010 at 9:08 am
Êàê çàðàáîòàòü â èíòåðíåòå…
èíñòðóêöèè ïî çàðàáîòêó â ñåòè…
Çàðàáîòîê â ñåòè said this on February 7th, 2010 at 11:02 am
Ïÿòèçâåçäî÷íûå îòåëè Åãèïòà…
Åãèïåò - æåì÷óæèíà ìèðîâîé êóëüòóðû…
Îòäûõ â Åãèïòå said this on February 8th, 2010 at 5:48 pm
Âèäû âåíòèëÿöèîííîãî îáîðóäîâàíèÿ…
Ñèñòåìû âåíòèëÿöèè…
Ïðîìûøëåííàÿ âåíòèëÿöèÿ said this on February 14th, 2010 at 1:28 am
Ãîðîä Ñèäå ðàñïîëîæåí íà ïîëóîñòðîâå â 75 êì îò Àíòàëüè…
Îòåëè ãîðîäà Ñèäå…
Îòäûõ â Òóðöèè said this on February 15th, 2010 at 1:09 pm
Ãîà íàõîäèòñÿ íà çàïàäå Èíäèè…
Ìóçûêà, òàíöû, ïðèêëàäíîå è óñòíîå òâîð÷åñòâî ãëóáîêèìè êîðíÿìè óõîäÿò â äóøó Ãîà, à ðèòìû ïóëüñèðóþò â ñåðäöàõ åãî æèòåëåé…
Îòåëè Ãîà said this on February 16th, 2010 at 7:32 am
Êëàññèôèêàöèÿ è íàçíà÷åíèå êàáåëåé…
Ýëåêòðîêàáåëè…
Ýëåêòðîòåõíè÷åñêîå îáîðóäîâàíèå] said this on February 17th, 2010 at 12:54 pm
Îòåëè Àëàíèè…
Êóðîðòû Òóðöèè…
Îòäûõ â Òóðöèè said this on February 18th, 2010 at 3:49 pm
Ïèëîðàìû…
Áð¸âíîïèëüíûå äèñêîâûå ñòàíêè…
Ëåñîïèëüíîå îáîðóäîâàíèå said this on February 20th, 2010 at 1:25 am
Ïàðèæ - ñòîëèöà Ôðàíöèè…
Ïðîâåäèòå îòïóñê âî Ôðàíöèè…
Îòåëè Ïàðèæà said this on February 22nd, 2010 at 3:15 am
Ïðàãà - Ãîðîä ñîòíè øïèëåé…
Ïðàãà - ñòîëèöà ×åõèè…
Îòåëè Ïðàãè said this on February 22nd, 2010 at 5:39 pm
Êàíàðñêèå îñòðîâà…
Âàëåíñèÿ…
Òóðû â Èñïàíèþ said this on February 23rd, 2010 at 3:36 pm
Ãèäðàâëè÷åñêèå íàñîñû…
Íàñîñû è ãèäðàâëè÷åñêîå îáîðóäîâàíèå…
Íàñîñû è ãèäðàâëè÷åñêîå îáîðóäîâàíèå said this on February 24th, 2010 at 1:12 pm
ïíåâìîàâòîìàòèêà…
Ïðîìûøëåííîå èñïîëüçîâàíèå ïíåâìàòèêè íà÷àëîñü áîëåå ñòà ëåò íàçàä…
Ïíåâìàòè÷åñêîå îáîðóäîâàíèå said this on February 25th, 2010 at 4:26 pm
Ìåêñèêà âîïëîùåíèå èäåàëüíîãî òóðèñòè÷åñêîãî íàïðàâëåíèÿ…
Ìåêñèêà ðàñïîëàãàåò ïî-íàñòîÿùåìó óíèêàëüíûìè âîçìîæíîñòÿìè äëÿ âñåõ âèäîâ òóðèçìà…
Îòåëè Ìåêñèêè said this on February 26th, 2010 at 5:50 pm
Ìåäèöèíñêèå èçäåëèÿ…
Ìåäèöèíñêàÿ òåõíèêà…
Ìåäèöèíñêîå îáîðóäîâàíèå said this on February 27th, 2010 at 4:05 pm
×åì òóðèñòîâ ïðèâëåêàåò Èñïàíèÿ…
5 äîâîäîâ çà îòäûõ â Èñïàíèè…
Îòäûõ â Èñïàíèè said this on March 1st, 2010 at 2:50 am
Îáùàÿ èíôîðìàöèÿ î Òóíèñå…
Äîñòîïðèìå÷àòåëüíîñòè Òóíèñà…
Îòäûõ â Òóíèñå said this on March 2nd, 2010 at 3:50 pm
Îáùàÿ èíôîðìàöèÿ î ×åðíîãîðèè…
Äîñòîïðèìå÷àòåëüíîñòè ×åðíîãîðèè…
Îòäûõ â ×åðíîãîðèè said this on March 2nd, 2010 at 10:48 pm
Êëàññèôèêàöèÿ ñòàíêîâ è îáîðóäîâàíèÿ ïî ìåòàëëó…
Ìåòàëëîðåæóùèé ñòàíîê…
Ìåòàëëîîáðàáàòûâàþùèå ñòàíêè said this on March 5th, 2010 at 2:22 am
Ïóòåøåñòâèå â Òàéëàíä…
Âåëèêîëåïíûé îòäûõ â Òàéëàíäå…
Îòåëè Òàéëàíäà said this on March 5th, 2010 at 2:09 pm
Óëüòðàçâóêîâîé íåðàçðóøàþùèé êîíòðîëü…
Óëüòðàçâóêîâûå ïðèáîðû…
Ðàäèîãðàôè÷åñêèé êîíòðîëü said this on March 7th, 2010 at 10:54 am